Before these reached the summit, and in ignorance that they were on the way, Colonel Thorneycroft, left in command by Coke's departure, decided that the position was untenable, and soon after 9.30 P.M.evacuated it.

Upon this Sir Redvers Buller commented: "Preparations for the second day's defence should have been organised during the day, and have been commenced at nightfall.

As this was not done I think Colonel Thorneycroft exercised a wise discretion." From this judgment Lord Roberts {p.260} dissented vigorously.

"I am of opinion that Lieut.-Colonel Thorneycroft's assumption of responsibility and authority was wholly inexcusable.

During the night the enemy's fire could not have been formidable, and ...