This man called him aside: "Did you notice that the first mate selected myself and mate in his watch?
He evidently intends to do my friend some mischief for the slash he made at him." He also informed Paul that he had a strong suspicion, which was shared by his mate that it was the captain's intention to take them all out to Valparaiso and not allow any to land at Malaga.

This suspicion was confirmed next day in Paul's mind by the captain who sent for him to come aft.

When he entered the cabin the captain said: "Young fellow, I like your appearance and wish you would change your mind and come on out with me to Valparaiso, I carry no boatswain, but I will give you that position and a pound a month extra, providing you can induce those two shell-backs who came aboard with you to do the same." To gain time, Paul answered that he would speak to them and report in the evening.

It was at that moment the farthest thought from his mind.
After a consultation with his shipmates, both of whom assured him they would never consent, it was agreed that they should feign willingness to go.

They knew that the captain had the power to hold them in the offing and prevent their landing so they determined to escape at the first opportunity at Malaga.