I have been accused of wishing to introduce among you a person whose intentions were hostile to your happiness--in matters of sentiment.

This supposition is an insult to the virtue of these ladies--nay more, an insult to their good taste.

Carolus Barbemuche is decidedly ugly." [Visible denial on the face of Phemie; noise under the table; it is Schaunard kicking her by way of correcting her compromising frankness.] "But," proceeded Colline, "what will reduce to powder the contemptible argument with which my opponent has armed himself against Carolus by taking advantage of your terrors, is the fact that the said Carolus is a Platonist." [Sensation among the men; uproar among the women.] This declaration of Colline's produced a reaction in favor of Carolus.
The philosopher wished to improve the effect of his eloquent and adroit defense.
"Now then," he continued, "I do not see what well founded prejudices can exist against this young man, who, after all, has rendered us a service.
As to myself, who am accused of acting thoughtlessly in wishing to introduce him among us, I consider this opinion an insult to my dignity.
I have acted in the affair with the wisdom of the serpent; if a formal vote does not maintain me this character for prudence, I offer my resignation." "Do you make it a cabinet question ?" asked Marcel.
"I do." The three consulted, and agreed by common consent to restore to the philosopher that high reputation for prudence which he claimed.

Colline then gave the floor to Marcel, who, somewhat relieved of his prejudices, declared that he might perhaps favor the adoption of the report.

But before the decisive and final vote which should open to Carolus the intimacy of the club, he put to the meeting this amendment: "WHEREAS, the introduction of a new member into our society is a grave matter, and a stranger might bring with him some elements of discord through ignorance of the habits, tempers, and opinions of his comrades, RESOLVED, that each member shall pass a say with the said Carolus, and investigate his manner of life, tastes, literary capacity, and wardrobe.