I recognized her the first time she came by a ring she always wore, which she had forgotten to remove.

The Court and jury will please allow for the contradictions which appear in the facts I have stated, which I myself am wholly unable to reconcile." A murmur of approval followed this testimony.

Bordin asked permission of the Court to address a few questions to the witness.
"Does the senator think that his abduction was due to other causes than the interests respecting property which the prosecution attributes to the prisoners ?" "I do," replied the senator, "but I am wholly ignorant of what the real motives were; for during a captivity of twenty days I saw and heard no one." "Do you think," said the public prosecutor, "that your chateau at Gondreville contains information, title-deeds, or other papers of value which would induce a search on the part of the Messieurs de Simeuse ?" "I do not think so," replied Malin; "I believe those gentlemen to be incapable of attempting to get possession of such papers by violence.
They had only to ask me for them to obtain them." "You burned certain papers in the park, did you not ?" said Monsieur de Gondreville, abruptly.
Malin looked at Grevin.

After exchanging a rapid glance with the notary, which Bordin intercepted, he replied that he had not burned any papers.
The public prosecutor having asked him to describe the ambush to which he had so nearly fallen a victim two years earlier, the senator replied that he had seen Michu watching him from the fork of a tree.

This answer, which agreed with Grevin's testimony, produced a great impression.
The four gentlemen remained impassible during the examination of their enemy, who seemed determined to overwhelm them with generosity.