[In the World War by Count Ottokar Czernin]@TWC D-Link book
In the World War

CHAPTER V
23/29

I am afraid that we have placed ourselves in a very awkward position with Wilson, which so easily could have been avoided, as it was not in accordance with my views that we had given a promise.
An expression of opinion is not a promise.

Without wishing to detract from its moral value, it has nevertheless a different legal character, and from the point of view of a third person has no legal authority in favour of that person as a promise.
By unnecessarily having admitted that we gave the Americans a promise we admit the existence of obligations on our side to them.
In spite of the fine and clever argument in our Note, it will be easy for the Americans to prove that our present procedure cannot be reconciled with the previous statement; if the statement was a promise, then the American Government has the right to look for the fulfilment of it, and we will then be in an awkward predicament.

I remarked in my notification that I would prefer to omit the admission that we had made any promise; there would have been the possibility of recurring to it.

By placing this weapon in their hands we have exposed ourselves to the danger of a checkmate, and I very much fear that we shall greatly regret it.
Naturally this remains between us.

But I was constrained to pour out my heart to you and justify my request that the text of all such important State documents which involve such far-reaching consequences may be sent to me in time for me to study and comment on them.


<<Back  Index  Next>>

D-Link book Top

TWC mobile books