This doctrine is also the theory that underlies the positions of the Definite Platform, and, we suppose, is assented to by its friends.
The Plea affirms, "The Lutheran doctrine maintains that the Sacraments have an _intrinsic value; but the Definite Platform seems to regard them as mere _signs_, which may have a tendency to _promote piety_, p.35.On this point we think our author has not clearly presented the point of difference between the friends of the Platform and the Plea.
We not only admit, but strenuously affirm, that the sacraments have an important _intrinsic_ influence.

The Platform thus describes it: "Baptism in adults is a means of making a profession of previous faith, or of being received into the visible church, as well as a _pledge_ and _condition_ of obtaining _those blessings purchased by Christ_, and offered to all who repent, believe in him and profess his name by baptism," p.30.As to the question, whether this influence is intrinsic or not, it is not touched in the Platform; although we doubt not its adherents very generally hold the affirmative.

But the real point of dispute is the _precise nature_ of the influence exerted by the sacraments.

The symbols _seem_ to regard _forgiveness of sins_, that is, justification, as the _immediate_ effect of every worthy reception of these ordinances; whilst the friends of the Platform hold this influence to consist in their tendency to produce that _living faith_, resulting from regeneration, which is the _only condition of pardon_, and without the possession of which God has not promised to forgive the sins of any one, no matter what outward duties he may perform.

For God will not forgive the sins of an unconverted sinner.