I am a lawyer, Miss Brant, and I have positive proof that this child is not bound to you in any way.

You took her from the orphanage on trial, exactly as you might hire a servant.

You did not even take the trouble to have yourself appointed her guardian.

You agreed to pay her for her work, but blows and harsh words are the only payment she has ever received at your hands.

She wishes to leave you because she can no longer endure life with you.