[Renaissance in Italy, Volumes 1 and 2 by John Addington Symonds]@TWC D-Link book
Renaissance in Italy, Volumes 1 and 2

CHAPTER XII
4/34

The grand defect of Flemish music, considered as an art of expression, was that it ignored propriety and neglected the libretto.

Instead of exercising original invention, instead of suiting melodies to words by appropriate combinations of sound and sense, the composers chose any musical themes that came to hand, and wrought them up into elaborate contrapuntal structures without regard for their book.
The first words of a passage from the Creed, for instance, were briefly indicated at the outset of the number: what followed was but a reiteration of the same syllables, and divided in the most arbitrary manner to suit the complicated descant which they had to serve.

The singers could not adapt their melodic phrases to the liturgical text, since sometimes passages of considerable length fell upon a couple of syllables, while on the contrary a long sentence might have no more than a bar or even less assigned to it.

They were consequently in the habit of drawling out or gabbling over the words, regardless of both sense and sentiment.

Nor was this all.


<<Back  Index  Next>>

D-Link book Top

TWC mobile books