That silence proved to be fatal.

In consequence of Mr.Conkling's silence and apparent indifference in 1884, Mr.Blaine lost New York, the pivotal State, and was defeated by Mr.Cleveland for the Presidency.

The falling off in the Republican vote in Mr.Conkling's home county alone caused the loss of the State and of the Presidency of the United States to the Republican party.
The quarrel between Blaine and Conkling originated when both of them were members of the House of Representatives.

In a controversy that took place between them on the floor of the House Mr.Blaine referred to Mr.
Conkling as the member from New York with the "turkey gobbler strut." That remark made the two men enemies for life.

That remark wounded Mr.
Conkling's pride; and he could never be induced to forgive the one who had so hurt him.
As a United States Senator Conkling was both felt and feared.