[The Ruins by C. F. Volney]@TWC D-Link book
The Ruins

CHAPTER XXI
2/27

It is time, if they are well founded, to give a solemn stamp to their certainty, and legitimize their existence.

Let us summon them this day to a general scrutiny, let each propound his creed, let the whole assembly be the judge, and let that alone be acknowledged as true which is so for the whole human race.
Then, by order of position, the representative of the first standard on the left was allowed to speak: "You are not permitted to doubt," said their chief, "that our doctrine is the only true and infallible one.

FIRST, it is revealed by God himself--" "So is ours," cried all the other standards, "and you are not permitted to doubt it." "But at least," said the legislator, "you must prove it, for we cannot believe what we do not know." "Our doctrine is proved," replied the first standard, "by numerous facts, by a multitude of miracles, by resurrections of the dead, by rivers dried up, by mountains removed--" "And we also have numberless miracles," cried all the others, and each began to recount the most incredible things.
"THEIR miracles," said the first standard, "are imaginary, or the fictions of the evil spirit, who has deluded them." "They are yours," said the others, "that are imaginary;" and each group, speaking of itself, cried out: "None but ours are true, all the others are false." The legislator then asked: "Have you living witnesses of the facts ?" "No," replied they all; "the facts are ancient, the witnesses are dead, but their writings remain." "Be it so," replied the legislator; "but if they contradict each other, who shall reconcile them ?" "Just judge!" cried one of the standards, "the proof that our witnesses have seen the truth is, that they died to confirm it; and our faith is sealed by the blood of martyrs." "And ours too," said the other standards; "we have thousands of martyrs who have died in the most excruciating torments, without ever denying the truth." Then the Christians of every sect, the Mussulmans, the Indians, the Japanese, recited endless legends of confessors, martyrs, penitents, etc.
And one of these parties, having denied the martyrology of the others: "Well," said they, "we will then die ourselves to prove the truth of our belief." And instantly a crowd of men, of every religion and of every sect, presented themselves to suffer the torments of death.

Many even began to tear their arms, and to beat their heads and breasts, without discovering any symptom of pain.
But the legislator, preventing them--"O men!" said he, "hear my words with patience.

If you die to prove that two and two make four, will your death add any thing to this truth ?" "No!" answered all.
"And if you die to prove that they make five, will that make them five ?" Again they all answered, "No." "What, then, is your persuasion to prove, if it changes not the existence of things?
Truth is one--your persuasions are various; many of you, therefore, are in error.


<<Back  Index  Next>>

D-Link book Top

TWC mobile books