[The Promise Of American Life by Herbert David Croly]@TWC D-Link bookThe Promise Of American Life CHAPTER XI 15/79
Neither is the betrayal attributed to some defect of organization, which neglects to give the representative individual a sufficient chance.
The responsibility for the failure is fastened on the selected individual himself, and the conclusion is drawn that the people cannot trust representatives to serve them honestly and efficiently.
The course of reasoning is precisely the same as that which prompted the Athenian democracy to order the execution of an unsuccessful general.
In the case of our state legislatures, a most flagrant betrayal of trust has assuredly occurred, but before inferring from this betrayal that selected individuals cannot be trusted to legislate properly on behalf of their constituents, it would be just as well to inquire whether individual incompetence and turpitude are any sufficient reason for this particular failure of representative institutions. As a matter of fact they are no sufficient reason.
When a large number of individuals to whom authority is delegated exercise that authority improperly, one may safely infer that the system is at fault as much as the individual.
<<Back Index Next>> D-Link book Top TWC mobile books
|