[Democracy In America Volume 1 (of 2) by Alexis de Toqueville]@TWC D-Link bookDemocracy In America Volume 1 (of 2) CHAPTER VIII: The Federal Constitution--Part IV 1/18
CHAPTER VIII: The Federal Constitution--Part IV. Procedure Of The Federal Courts Natural weakness of the judiciary power in confederations--Legislators ought to strive as much as possible to bring private individuals, and not States, before the Federal Courts--How the Americans have succeeded in this--Direct prosecution of private individuals in the Federal Courts--Indirect prosecution of the States which violate the laws of the Union--The decrees of the Supreme Court enervate but do not destroy the provincial laws. I have shown what the privileges of the Federal courts are, and it is no less important to point out the manner in which they are exercised.
The irresistible authority of justice in countries in which the sovereignty in undivided is derived from the fact that the tribunals of those countries represent the entire nation at issue with the individual against whom their decree is directed, and the idea of power is thus introduced to corroborate the idea of right.
But this is not always the case in countries in which the sovereignty is divided; in them the judicial power is more frequently opposed to a fraction of the nation than to an isolated individual, and its moral authority and physical strength are consequently diminished.
In federal States the power of the judge is naturally decreased, and that of the justiciable parties is augmented.
The aim of the legislator in confederate States ought therefore to be to render the position of the courts of justice analogous to that which they occupy in countries where the sovereignty is undivided; in other words, his efforts ought constantly to tend to maintain the judicial power of the confederation as the representative of the nation, and the justiciable party as the representative of an individual interest. Every government, whatever may be its constitution, requires the means of constraining its subjects to discharge their obligations, and of protecting its privileges from their assaults.
<<Back Index Next>> D-Link book Top TWC mobile books
|