He was a consistent liberal as far as he felt liberalism to be perfectly safe, but he had the most vivid dislike of Gladstone and his ways; a dislike dating from their earliest contact in the House of Commons, long before Gladstone adopted Home Rule.

And to this nature the character of MacDonald responded as the natural executive.

The following letter which I received from Mr.Walter in reply to mine of grief at the death of MacDonald, tells the story of their relation better than I can.
Bearwood, December 19, 1889.
Dear Mr.Stillman,--One appreciates true sympathy at such a time as this, and none that I have received has touched me more than yours.

It is sad indeed to go down to the office and be no more greeted with MacDonald's cheery voice and kindly look.

His illness was unexpected and its progress rapid.