Was it during a revolt on board?
Brave man that he was, he would not betray his captain, and perhaps he was massacred." "Did Hearne dwell on this, boatswain ?" "Yes, but he added: 'It is very sad for you, Master Holt! The captain of the _Grampus_, according to what I have been told, was abandoned, being placed in a small boat with one or two of his men--and who knows if your brother was not along with him ?'" "And what next ?" "Then, Mr.Jeorling, he added: 'Did it never occur to you to ask Dirk Peters to enlighten you on the subject ?' 'Yes, once,' replied Martin Holt, 'I questioned the halfbreed about it, and never did I see a man so overcome.

He replied in so low a voice that I could scarcely understand him, 'I know not--I know not--' and he ran away with his face buried in his hands." "Was that all you heard of the conversation, boatswain ?" "That was all, Mr.Jeorling, and I thought it so strange that I wished to inform you of it." "And what conclusion did you draw from it ?" "Nothing, except that I look upon the sealing-master as a scoundrel of the deepest dye, perfectly capable of working in secret for some evil purpose with which he would like to associate Martin Holt!" What did Hearne's new attitude mean?
Why did he strive to gain Martin Holt, one of the best of the crew, as an ally?
Why did he recall the scenes of the _Grampus_?
Did Hearne know more of this matter of Dirk Peters and Ned Holt than the others; this secret of which the half-breed and I believed ourselves to be the sole possessors?
The doubt caused me serious uneasiness.

However, I took good care not to say anything of it to Dirk Peters.

If he had for a moment suspected that Hearne spoke of what happened on board the _Grampus_, if he had heard that the rascal (as Hurliguerly called him, and not without reason) constantly talked to Martin Holt about his brother, I really do not know what would have happened.
In short, whatever the intentions of Hearne might be, it was dreadful to think that our sailing-master, on whose fidelity Captain Len Guy ought to be able to count, was in conspiracy with him.
The sealing-master must have a strong motive for acting in this way.
What it was I could not imagine.

Although the crew seemed to have abandoned every thougilt of mutiny, a strict watch was kept, especially on Hearne.
Besides, the situation must soon change, at least so far as the schooner was concerned.