[What is Property? by P. J. Proudhon]@TWC D-Link book
What is Property?

CHAPTER IV
32/109

But, in the first place, since the proprietors no longer labor, their consumption is, according to economical principles, unproductive; consequently, the previous condition of the community--when the labor of one hundred was rewarded by no products--is superseded by one in which the products of one hundred are consumed without labor.

The deficit is always the same, whichever the column of the account in which it is expressed.

Either the maxims of political economy are false, or else property, which contradicts them, is impossible.
The economists--regarding all unproductive consumption as an evil, as a robbery of the human race--never fail to exhort proprietors to moderation, labor, and economy; they preach to them the necessity of making themselves useful, of remunerating production for that which they receive from it; they launch the most terrible curses against luxury and laziness.

Very beautiful morality, surely; it is a pity that it lacks common sense.

The proprietor who labors, or, as the economists say, WHO MAKES HIMSELF USEFUL, is paid for this labor and utility; is he, therefore, any the less idle as concerns the property which he does not use, and from which he receives an income?
His condition, whatever he may do, is an unproductive and FELONIOUS one; he cannot cease to waste and destroy without ceasing to be a proprietor.
But this is only the least of the evils which property engenders.
Society has to maintain some idle people, whether or no.


<<Back  Index  Next>>

D-Link book Top

TWC mobile books