[What is Property? by P. J. Proudhon]@TWC D-Link bookWhat is Property? CHAPTER IV 30/109
each laborer's consumption is reduced as follows: wheat, 0.63; wine and vegetables, 0.09; clothing and shoes, 0.054; furniture and iron-work, 0.045; other products, 0.072; schooling, 0.0063; administration, 0.0018; mass, 0.0009.Total 0.9. The laborer has produced 1; he consumes only 0.9.He loses, then, one-tenth of the price of his labor; his production still costs more than it is worth.
On the other hand, the tenth received by the proprietors is no less a waste; for, being laborers themselves, they, like the others, possess in the nine-tenths of their product the wherewithal to live: they want for nothing.
Why should they wish their proportion of bread, wine, meat, clothes, shelter, &c., to be doubled, if they can neither consume nor exchange them? Then farm-rent, with them as with the rest of the laborers, is a waste, and perishes in their hands.
Extend the hypothesis, increase the number and variety of the products, you still have the same result. Hitherto, we have considered the proprietor as taking part in the production, not only (as Say says) by the use of his instrument, but in an effective manner and by the labor of his hands.
Now, it is easy to see that, under such circumstances, property will never exist.
<<Back Index Next>> D-Link book Top TWC mobile books
|