[What is Property? by P. J. Proudhon]@TWC D-Link book
What is Property?

CHAPTER III
88/90

Let us not prolong this catalogue--so easy to extend--lest we be accused of uttering commonplaces.

All industries are united by mutual relations in a single group; all productions do reciprocal service as means and end; all varieties of talent are but a series of changes from the inferior to the superior.
Now, this undisputed and indisputable fact of the general participation in every species of product makes all individual productions common; so that every product, coming from the hands of the producer, is mortgaged in advance by society.

The producer himself is entitled to only that portion of his product, which is expressed by a fraction whose denominator is equal to the number of individuals of which society is composed.

It is true that in return this same producer has a share in all the products of others, so that he has a claim upon all, just as all have a claim upon him; but is it not clear that this reciprocity of mortgages, far from authorizing property, destroys even possession?
The laborer is not even possessor of his product; scarcely has he finished it, when society claims it.
"But," it will be answered, "even if that is so--even if the product does not belong to the producer--still society gives each laborer an equivalent for his product; and this equivalent, this salary, this reward, this allowance, becomes his property.

Do you deny that this property is legitimate?
And if the laborer, instead of consuming his entire wages, chooses to economize,--who dare question his right to do so ?" The laborer is not even proprietor of the price of his labor, and cannot absolutely control its disposition.


<<Back  Index  Next>>

D-Link book Top

TWC mobile books