[What is Property? by P. J. Proudhon]@TWC D-Link book
What is Property?

CHAPTER III
49/90

A force of one thousand men working twenty days has been paid the same wages that one would be paid for working fifty-five years; but this force of one thousand has done in twenty days what a single man could not have accomplished, though he had labored for a million centuries.

Is the exchange an equitable one?
Once more, no; when you have paid all the individual forces, the collective force still remains to be paid.
Consequently, there remains always a right of collective property which you have not acquired, and which you enjoy unjustly.
Admit that twenty days' wages suffice to feed, lodge, and clothe this multitude for twenty days: thrown out of employment at the end of that time, what will become of them, if, as fast as they create, they abandon their creations to the proprietors who will soon discharge them?
While the proprietor, firm in his position (thanks to the aid of all the laborers), dwells in security, and fears no lack of labor or bread, the laborer's only dependence is upon the benevolence of this same proprietor, to whom he has sold and surrendered his liberty.

If, then, the proprietor, shielding himself behind his comfort and his rights, refuses to employ the laborer, how can the laborer live?
He has ploughed an excellent field, and cannot sow it; he has built an elegant and commodious house, and cannot live in it; he has produced all, and can enjoy nothing.
Labor leads us to equality.

Every step that we take brings us nearer to it; and if laborers had equal strength, diligence, and industry, clearly their fortunes would be equal also.

Indeed, if, as is pretended,--and as we have admitted,--the laborer is proprietor of the value which he creates, it follows:-- 1.


<<Back  Index  Next>>

D-Link book Top

TWC mobile books