[What is Property? by P. J. Proudhon]@TWC D-Link bookWhat is Property? CHAPTER II 33/57
In the state of Nature or isolation, the strongest and most skilful (that is, those best provided with innate property) stand the best chance of obtaining acquired property.
Now, it is to prevent this encroachment and the war which results therefrom, that a balance (justice) has been employed, and covenants (implied or expressed) agreed upon: it is to correct, as far as possible, inequality of innate property by equality of acquired property.
As long as the division remains unequal, so long the partners remain enemies; and it is the purpose of the covenants to reform this state of things.
Thus we have, on the one hand, isolation, inequality, enmity, war, robbery, murder; on the other, society, equality, fraternity, peace, and love. Choose between them! M.Joseph Dutens--a physician, engineer, and geometrician, but a very poor legist, and no philosopher at all--is the author of a "Philosophy of Political Economy," in which he felt it his duty to break lances in behalf of property.
His reasoning seems to be borrowed from Destutt de Tracy.
<<Back Index Next>> D-Link book Top TWC mobile books
|