[What is Property? by P. J. Proudhon]@TWC D-Link book
What is Property?

CHAPTER II
26/57

Destutt de Tracy cannot escape equality.

On this theory, men, while in a state of ESTRANGEMENT, are under no obligations to each other; they all have the right to satisfy their needs without regard to the needs of others, and consequently the right to exercise their power over Nature, each according to his strength and ability.

That involves the greatest inequality of wealth.

Inequality of conditions, then, is the characteristic feature of estrangement or barbarism: the exact opposite of Rousseau's idea.
But let us look farther:-- "Restrictions of these rights and this duty commence at the time when covenants, either implied or expressed, are agreed upon.

Then appears for the first time justice and injustice; that is, the balance between the rights of one and the rights of another, which up to that time were necessarily equal." Listen: RIGHTS WERE EQUAL; that means that each individual had the right to SATISFY HIS NEEDS WITHOUT REFERENCE TO THE NEEDS OF OTHERS.


<<Back  Index  Next>>

D-Link book Top

TWC mobile books