[What is Property? by P. J. Proudhon]@TWC D-Link bookWhat is Property? CHAPTER II 25/57
THINE and MINE oftener indicate a relation,--YOUR country, YOUR parish, YOUR tailor, YOUR milkmaid; MY chamber, MY seat at the theatre, MY company and MY battalion in the National Guard.
In the former sense, we may sometimes say MY labor, MY skill, MY virtue; never MY grandeur nor MY majesty: in the latter sense only, MY field, MY house, MY vineyard, MY capital,--precisely as the banker's clerk says MY cash-box.
In short, THINE and MINE are signs and expressions of personal, but equal, rights; applied to things outside of us, they indicate possession, function, use, not property. It does not seem possible, but, nevertheless, I shall prove, by quotations, that the whole theory of our author is based upon this paltry equivocation. "Prior to all covenants, men are, not exactly, as Hobbes says, in a state of HOSTILITY, but of ESTRANGEMENT.
In this state, justice and injustice are unknown; the rights of one bear no relation to the rights of another.
All have as many rights as needs, and all feel it their duty to satisfy those needs by any means at their command." Grant it; whether true or false, it matters not.
<<Back Index Next>> D-Link book Top TWC mobile books
|