[What is Property? by P. J. Proudhon]@TWC D-Link bookWhat is Property? CHAPTER II 19/57
Now, what have we a right to possess? That which is required for our labor and consumption; Cicero's comparison of the earth to a theatre proves it.
According to that, each one may take what place he will, may beautify and adorn it, if he can; it is allowable: but he must never allow himself to overstep the limit which separates him from another.
The doctrine of Cicero leads directly to equality; for, occupation being pure toleration, if the toleration is mutual (and it cannot be otherwise) the possessions are equal. Grotius rushes into history; but what kind of reasoning is that which seeks the origin of a right, said to be natural, elsewhere than in Nature? This is the method of the ancients: the fact exists, then it is necessary, then it is just, then its antecedents are just also. Nevertheless, let us look into it. "Originally, all things were common and undivided; they were the property of all." Let us go no farther.
Grotius tells us how this original communism came to an end through ambition and cupidity; how the age of gold was followed by the age of iron, &c.
So that property rested first on war and conquest, then on treaties and agreements.
<<Back Index Next>> D-Link book Top TWC mobile books
|