"Without doubt the Gods have granted great gifts to our young friend, but it remains to be proved how he will use them.

I perceive a certain freedom of thought in the youth, which pains me deeply.

Although in his poems his flexible style certainly follows the prescribed forms, his ideas transcend all tradition; and even in the hymns intended for the ears of the people I find turns of thought, which might well be called treason to the mysteries which only a few months ago he swore to keep secret.

For instance he says--and we sing--and the laity hear-- "One only art Thou, Thou Creator of beings; And Thou only makest all that is created.
And again-- He is one only, Alone, without equal; Dwelling alone in the holiest of holies." [Hymn to Amon preserved in a papyrus roll at Bulaq, and deciphered by Grehaut and L.Stern.] Such passages as these ought not to be sung in public, at least in times like ours, when new ideas come in upon us from abroad, like the swarms of locusts from the East." "Spoken to my very soul!" cried the treasurer of the temple, "Ameni initiated this boy too early into the mysteries." "In my opinion, and I am his teacher," said Gagabu, "our brotherhood may be proud of a member who adds so brilliantly to the fame of our temple.
The people hear the hymns without looking closely at the meaning of the words.

I never saw the congregation more devout, than when the beautiful and deeply-felt song of praise was sung at the feast of the stairs." [A particularly solemn festival in honor of Amon-Chem, held in the temple of Medinet-Abu.] "Pentaur was always thy favorite," said the former speaker.