And she sat down on a chair facing him.
"Let's see, you sleep in one of the top rooms, Madame Victoire.

It has a dormer window, set in the roof, hasn't it ?" said Guerchard, in the same polite, pleasant voice.
"Yes; yes.

But what has that got to do with it ?" said Victoire.
"Please answer my questions," said Guerchard sharply.

"You went to sleep in your room.

Did you hear any noise on the roof ?" "On the roof?
How should I hear it on the roof?
There wouldn't be any noise on the roof," said Victoire.
"You heard nothing on the roof ?" said Guerchard.
"No; the noise I heard was down here," said Victoire.
"Yes, and you came down to see what was making it.