[A Second Book of Operas by Henry Edward Krehbiel]@TWC D-Link book
A Second Book of Operas

CHAPTER XV
10/12

But every change which has come under the notice of this reviewer has been to its betterment and made for its practical presentation.

It is said that the popular scenes were curtailed because they represented the voice of the democracy.

But there is still so much choral work in the opera that the judgment of the operatic audiences of to-day is likely to pronounce against it measurably on that account.
For, splendid as the choral element in the work is, a chorus is not looked upon with admiration as a dramatic element by the ordinary opera lover.

There was a lack of the feminine element in the opera, and to remedy this Moussorgsky had to introduce the Polish bride of the False Dmitri and give the pair a love scene, and incidentally a polonaise; but the love scene is uninteresting until its concluding measures, and these are too Meyerbeerian to call for comment beyond the fact that Meyerbeer, the much contemned, would have done better.

As for the polonaise, Tschaikowsky has written a more brilliant one for his "Eugene Onegin." The various scores of the opera which have been printed show that Moussorgsky, with all his genius, was at sea even when it came to applying the principles of the Young Russian School, of which he is set down as a strong prop, to dramatic composition.


<<Back  Index  Next>>

D-Link book Top

TWC mobile books